Turning to pop culture when picking out your Halloween costume makes for an easy selection process. But choosing a character with unnatural skin tones can present a dilemma.

The Simpsons may be an iconic television show, but attempting the mac-‘n’-cheese-colored skin is tricky. Don’t even get us started on recreating Krusty the Clown.

Check out these tributes to Springfield’s finest, ranging from not half-bad to WTF.